Being arrested and charged with a battery or assault offense can change your world as you know it in a split second. One minute you are leading your life freely, and the next you are before a prosecutor who is trying to portray you to society as a criminal. It is scary and stressful, and if you do not fully understand the charges you are facing, you can easily feel lost. In addition, a conviction of an assault or battery offense can result in severe consequences, including a heavy fine and a lengthy incarceration period. That said, you need to seek legal help, and an attorney is the better-placed person to help you.

At Orange County Criminal Defense, we can help you develop a compelling defense to prove your innocence. We boast knowledgeable criminal defense lawyers who will collect evidence and facts to support your defense. Whether you were involved in a dispute that later escalated, you have been accused of doing something that never happened as the victim describes, or you only acted in self-defense. Now that they see you as the aggressor, we will help you achieve the best possible outcome. Contact us today for a free consultation.

An Overview of Assault and Battery

Due to the nature of the crime, prosecutors generally file battery and assault charges together. However, these are two separate crimes described under two distinct Penal Code Sections. The crime of simple assault or assault is described under Penal Code (PC) Section 240, while that of simple battery or battery is described under Penal Code Section 242.

PC 240, Assault

PC 240 describes an assault as a criminal attempt, accompanied by the present capability, to perpetrate violent harm on someone else. Simply put, it means if you committed an act that might have led to physical injury to another person, even when you did not make contact with the person, you could be accused of assault.

The prosecuting attorney must demonstrate these criminal elements for the jury to convict you of assault:

  • You willfully committed an act that, by its nature, would probably and directly lead to the use of force on someone else.
  • When you committed that act, you knew about the facts that would make a reasonable individual realize your action would probably and directly lead to the use of force on someone.
  • When you committed that act, you possessed the present capability to use force on someone.

Use of force entails any offensive or harmful touching. In assault cases, however, there need not be any touching or contact for you to be found criminally liable. In other words, you need not actually use force against the victim. All that matters is that you committed some act that would likely lead to force being used on the said victim.

For example, if you throw a punch at someone and miss, that is considered assault. When you hurl an object at somebody, and it does not hit them, that is assault. And should you forcefully lunge towards somebody in a manner that leads them to believe you are going to hurt them, it can be considered assault, too. In short, assault charges are the attempt and the threat, not the outcome.

You willfully act when you commit an act willingly or purposely. You need not have meant to violate the law, gain any benefit, or harm anybody else for the jury to convict you.

Lastly, for the jury to find you criminally liable for an assault, you need to have known that your actions may result in the use of force. That means you need not have meant to apply force upon the victim to have committed assault. The D.A. only needs to show that, given those circumstances, it was highly probable that your actions would result in force being used.

PC 242, Battery

PC 242 describes the crime of battery as the unlawful and willful application of violence or force against someone. For the judge to convict you of battery, the prosecution must prove the following criminal elements:

  • You unlawfully and willfully touched somebody else harmfully or offensively
  • You touched them while not defending yourself or another, nor were you reasonably disciplining a minor.

Per this definition, a battery offense takes things a step further from assault. Unlike the crime of assault, a battery necessitates actual bodily contact. Any form of touching, no matter how slight, counts as a battery as long as it is done rudely or offensively. The touching need not inflict injury or pain.

That said, the prosecution attorney can charge you with battery even if your touching could not or did not cause any type of injury. The touching need not be direct either; you can still be accused of an assault even if your touching was indirect, that is, by making an object touch the involved victim.

A grab, a shove, spitting on somebody, or even a slap can be deemed a battery. The D.A. is only required to show that you made deliberate bodily contact with the accuser in an offensive or harmful way.

The Difference Between Battery and Assault

The primary difference between a battery and an assault is whether or not there was physical contact. "Assault" refers to an act that may cause unwanted touching or physical harm to a person. On the contrary, a battery is the actual infliction of violence or force on another person. That means if you and the victim did not make bodily contact, it is considered an assault, and if there was contact, it is often both battery and assault.

The most straightforward way of explaining the contrast between battery and assault is that a battery does necessarily entail actual bodily contact, while assault does not. Put otherwise, an assault is an attempted or incomplete battery, while battery is a completed assault. Remember, however, that any amount of offensive or harmful contact, regardless of how slight, can cause an assault to turn into a battery.

Understanding the difference between these two offenses and whether you are facing battery or assault is essential because defense strategies for each charge differ.

For an assault charge, the prosecuting attorney must demonstrate that you possessed the present capability to perform the act. If you did not actually have the means to inflict harm—for example, you were so far away from the crime scene, or the supposed threat was not credible—that is a solid defense. For a battery charge, the primary factor is the bodily contact. If the prosecuting attorney cannot prove that deliberate contact happened, the charge cannot hold.

Aggravated Factors for Battery and Assault Charges

Battery and assault each have various aggravating circumstances that can enhance the consequences of a criminal conviction. Both battery and assault are aggravated when you perpetrate the crime on a school employee, police officer, or any other peace officer, such as a firefighter. Aggravated assault occurs when you perpetrate assault:

  • Using caustic chemicals
  • Using a gun
  • Using a dangerous weapon that is not classified as a gun
  • Using a stun gun
  • In a way likely to cause great bodily harm
  • Intending to perpetrate a sexual felony

On the other hand, a battery violation can be aggravated if the following is true:

  • The battery produces severe bodily injury, or
  • The battery is committed against a custodial officer

These aggravating circumstances can substantially enhance the possible consequences following a conviction. Perpetrating an assault intending to perpetrate a felony, such as sexual battery, for example, is considered a felony assault crime that is punishable by six years in prison.

The Consequences of Assault and Battery

Simple assault is a misdemeanor violation. The consequences upon a conviction include six months in jail, misdemeanor probation, and a fine not exceeding $1,000. The maximum court fine for assault rises to $2,000 when the involved victim is a parking control officer on duty. Meanwhile, you will be subject to a maximum court fine of $2,000 and no more than a year in custody if the involved victim was on duty as a:

  • A nurse or a doctor providing emergency medical care
  • Firefighter
  • Animal control officer
  • Peace officer (a police officer or any other peace officer)
  • Paramedic
  • Lifeguard enforcement officer
  • Traffic officer
  • Process server
  • EMT (Emergency Medical Technician)
  • A member of a search and rescue team

To be subject to these enhanced penalties, you need to have been aware that the involved victim was doing their formal duties at the time of the assault.

Lastly, if you supposedly assaulted a retail establishment worker who was on duty, PC 490.8 allows the judge to grant a 2-year protective order preventing you from going into the establishment. Should you break the terms of the protective order, you will be subject to additional charges.

Like assault, a battery is also a misdemeanor violation. The consequences upon conviction include misdemeanor probation, a fine not exceeding $2,000, and up to six months in jail. Based on the facts surrounding the case, you may also be ordered to counseling (like anger management) or community service.

If you batter an EMT, a firefighter, a peace officer, or another public servant mentioned above, and the person sustains any form of injury, you might be accused of the more severe offense of battery on a police or peace officer. This violation is considered a wobbler, meaning the prosecution can charge it as a felony or a misdemeanor based on the facts of the case and your criminal history.

Also, like assault, you will be subject to a restraining order for two years if you commit a battery against a retail establishment worker who was on duty. The restraining order bars you from going into the retail establishment.

Defending Against Assault and Battery Charges

You can use various defenses to beat assault and battery charges, depending on the facts of the case. You want to have an experienced attorney by your side to help present these defenses in a highly convincing manner to the jury. Depending on how the defenses are presented, your charges can be lowered via a plea deal or dismissed. Some of these defense strategies include the following:

Your Act Was Not Willful

Although you need not have meant to hurt somebody, you need to have acted willfully to be convicted of a battery or assault. Therefore, if the assault or battery was completely accidental, you could argue the legal defense of accident.

For example, suppose you unintentionally shove somebody during a commotion in a big crowd or hit them with something you are carrying. The victim then files battery charges. In this case, the court should not convict you of battery if you never acted intentionally.

You Were Defending Yourself or Someone Else

The defense of self-defense or defense of another can apply to battery or assault charges. You can argue this defense when all these are factual:

  • You had a valid reason to think or believe you or somebody else was in immediate danger of being touched illegally or suffering bodily harm
  • You had a valid reason to think or believe you needed to apply imminent force to fight against the looming danger
  • The force you applied was reasonably necessary to fight against that danger and not more

But words, regardless of how offensive, cannot justifiably provoke an assault or a battery. So, you can only argue that you defended yourself or another if you had reason to believe you or someone else faced danger of physical injury or an illegal touching.

Parental Right to Discipline a Minor

The defense of parental right to discipline a child applies to battery charges. Sometimes, charges of battery are filed against parents in relation to child abuse. But you would not have committed any offense if you acted within your legal rights to impose corporal punishment. The law allows parents to utilize physical force to discipline their children, provided the force is reasonable and not excessive, given the circumstances.

You Lacked the Capability to Use Violence or Force

To be convicted of assault, the prosecution must establish that you possessed the present ability to use force on the accuser. Just because the supposed victim was scared does not mean you possessed the capability to harm them. When presenting this defense, your legal counsel will rely on surveillance video and eyewitnesses to prove you were incapable of inflicting force upon the victim.

False Accusations

Since it is not a requirement that the supposed victim suffer actual harm for assault or battery charges to hold, a person can easily falsely accuse another of assaulting or battering them. An aggrieved individual can falsely accuse another out of malice, jealousy, desire for revenge, or anger. If that is the case, your lawyer can interview witnesses and gather evidence to uncover the actual story. Often, lawyers use the victim's own words (recorded on voicemail, from eyewitnesses, or in text messages) against the victim.

In certain cases, your attorney can meet the prosecutor right after you are arrested in a so-called profile intervention and attempt to convince them not to file charges to begin with. If that happens, it is the best-case scenario, as it will enable you to avoid court altogether.

Crimes Related to Assault and Battery

A wide range of crimes are related to the crimes of battery and assault, meaning they share some elements. Because of the connection, the prosecution can charge you with any of those crimes alongside or instead of assault or battery based on the circumstances. Some of the crimes related to assault and battery include the following:

PC 243(d), Aggravated Battery Inflicting Severe Bodily Injury

Under PC 243 (d), it is a crime to commit aggravated battery, also known as battery causing severe bodily injury. Severe bodily injury refers to any severe impairment of a person's physical condition, irrespective of whether it necessitates medical treatment.

Based on the circumstances, aggravated battery may be considered a misdemeanor punishable by up to 12 months in custody and a $1,000 fine. It can also be a felony punishable by up to 4 years in jail and a $10,000 fine. You will be subject to three to six more years in jail if the involved victim suffered great bodily harm.

PC 245(a)(2), Assault Using a Gun

PC 245(a)(2) prohibits assaulting someone using a rifle, pistol, semiautomatic firearm, shotgun, 0.50 BMG rifle, assault weapon, or machine gun. The assault might take various forms, including the following:

  • Actually shooting the victim
  • Firing the firearm at the victim
  • Pistol-whipping or striking the victim
  • Pointing the gun at the victim

Violating PC 245(a)(2) is deemed a wobbler offense. A misdemeanor carries a fine of up to $1,000 and a maximum of 12 months in jail. A felony conviction carries two, three, or four years in custody (plus three to six years if the involved victim suffered great bodily harm) and a maximum fine of $10,000.

PC 245(a)(1), Assault with a Deadly Weapon (ADW)

PC 245(a)(1) describes the crime of ADW as attacking or trying to attack someone else using a weapon that can cause great bodily harm or death. This crime is a wobbler. A misdemeanor carries up to 12 months in jail and a court fine of $1,000. A conviction for a felony is punishable by two, three, or four years in custody (plus three to six years if the victim sustained great bodily harm) and a court fine of no more than $10,000.

PC 244, Assault Using Caustic Chemicals

According to PC 244, you commit the crime of assault using caustic chemicals when you throw or place flammable or caustic substances on somebody, intending to disfigure, hurt, or injure them. This crime is always a felony. If convicted, the consequences include two to four years in prison and a $10,000 court fine.

PC 243(e)(1), Domestic Battery

Section 243(e)(1) of the Penal Code describes domestic battery as willfully and illegally touching a romantic partner in an offensive and harmful manner. A romantic or intimate partner includes a coparent, cohabitant, a former or current spouse, a dating partner, or a fiancé(e).

You can be found criminally liable for domestic battery even when the victim sustained no physical injury from your physical contact. What matters is that you utilized violence or force against them. Domestic battery is a misdemeanor. A conviction carries a jail sentence of no more than 12 months and up to $2,000 in fines.

PC 243.4, Sexual Battery

Section 243.4 of the Penal Code criminalizes sexual battery, defined as touching someone else's private parts without permission for sexual abuse, gratification, or arousal. Sexual battery is also known as sexual assault. The crime is often a misdemeanor, but it could be a felony if the victim were unconscious, medically incapacitated, or restrained.

A misdemeanor sexual battery is punishable by a six-month jail term (or 12 months if an aggravating circumstance was present) and a court fine of $2,000 (or $3,000 when the victim involved was your employee). You will also be required to register as a level 1 sex offender for ten years. If convicted of a felony, you would face a prison sentence of two, three, or four years (or an additional three to five years if the involved victim was severely injured) and a maximum fine of $10,000. You will also be mandated to comply with the level 3 sex offender registration requirement for life.

Find a Knowledgeable Criminal Defense Counsel Near Me

Even though they are both misdemeanors, an assault or battery conviction can still negatively impact your life. For one, you may lose your freedom and pay a heavy fine, which may affect your financial situation. You want to consult a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney as soon as you are charged to stand a chance of avoiding these consequences.

At Orange County Criminal Defense, we have defended clients accused of battery, assault, and every other crime for several years. With our in-depth knowledge and experience, our lawyers know the local courts and prosecutors and understand how to handle a wide range of charges. We do not present a general defense; we tailor each case’s defense to the specific facts and fight aggressively to have charges dismissed, reduced, or beaten during trial. We treat every case like it were the most critical one we have because, to our clients, it is. Call us today at 657-600-0945 for your complimentary case evaluation.