Workers' compensation fraud happens when a person provides misleading or false information to receive benefits they do not deserve. It is a wobbler offense, meaning that the prosecutor can file misdemeanor or felony charges against the perpetrator. If convicted of a misdemeanor, you could receive a jail sentence of one year, while a felony conviction is punishable by a maximum of five years in prison. A conviction for workers' compensation fraud can also lead to other devastating consequences. For example, you could become ineligible for other critical benefits.

Thus, you should engage a skilled criminal lawyer if in Orange County and are accused of workers’ compensation fraud. Our competent lawyers at Orange County Criminal Defense can help you work on your defense for the best possible outcome in your case. They can use compelling evidence to counter the prosecutor’s evidence and to convince the court to dismiss or reduce your charges.

The Legal Definition of Workers’ Compensation Fraud

Workers' Compensation is a private insurance scheme that provides monthly payments and medical care to workers injured on the job. It provides the financial support an injured employee needs during recovery before resuming work or earning income again. Employers contribute to the workers’ compensation program to avoid being held responsible for damages resulting from workplace injuries. Thus, when you are injured in your workplace, you can file for benefits according to the nature and severity of your injuries. However, you cannot sue your employer even if they were negligent in causing your injuries.

Workers’ compensation fraud is a type of fraud committed by employers or employees for different reasons. Some employers commit this kind of fraud to avoid contributing to their workers’ insurance program. Some employees commit this fraud to receive more benefits than they deserve or receive undeserved benefits. It is considered serious under the insurance fraud laws because of the financial losses it causes insurance companies that run these programs. Thus, you will likely face serious charges and possible severe penalties if convicted of defrauding the compensation program.

Typically, a fraud charge happens when you provide misleading or false information for fraudulent reasons. In this case, a worker is guilty if they provide misleading information to get insurance benefits they do not deserve. When this happens, the police will investigate the matter and build a case against you, which the DA will then file in court. However, the prosecutor must prove all the elements of the case for the court to find you guilty.

Here are some ways you can commit this type of fraud:

  • Knowingly presenting or making false or fraudulent statements to obtain or deny benefits
  • Making fraudulent or false statements about a worker’s eligibility for compensation benefits to discourage them from claiming benefits that they deserve
  • Knowingly conspiring, aiding, or abetting the commission of workers' compensation insurance fraud
  • Preparing and submitting several claims to receive multiple benefits for one injury
  • Submitting a falsified claim for a particular benefit provided under the workers' compensation program for an injury that does not exist
  • Soliciting or accepting payment from a person who you know intends to defraud the workers' compensation insurance program.

The primary workers’ compensation fraud law is outlined in California Insurance Code Section 1871. You are guilty if you do the following:

  • If you knowingly provide dishonest information or cause someone to provide dishonest information to receive or deny benefits, or
  • Knowingly offer or cause someone to offer a false written or verbal statement in opposition to, or in support of, a benefits claim, or
  • You knowingly conspire with someone, or aid, or abet, a person to engage in workers’ compensation fraud, or
  • You knowingly make a false report or cause someone to provide a false report concerning their eligibility to benefits, intending to discourage a deserving beneficiary from pursuing or filing a claim

These are the elements of the crime that the district attorney must prove to receive a guilty verdict. Let us look at each in detail to understand this law even better:

Benefits Under the Workers’ Compensation Program

Recall that this is the type of fraud committed against workers' compensation insurance benefits. This is a private insurance scheme that all employers in California are expected to contribute to. In addition to ensuring that injured workers receive adequate medical treatment, death benefits, and temporary or permanent disability benefits after a workplace injury, this program protects employers from liability in case of a workplace accident. If an employer contributes as expected for all their workers, their injured workers can claim monthly payments until they are fully recovered and ready to return to work.

In California, the workers’ compensation scheme operates under a no-fault insurance system. Thus, an employee should not hold their employer responsible for their workplace injury, regardless of fault. They also do not need to prove liability to receive compensation benefits.

Example: As William and Joey are playing around in the office, William accidentally spills some water on the floor. Unfortunately, before William realizes it, Charlie slips and falls hard on the floor, seriously injuring his back. Charlie needs to take a long break from work to recover from the injury.

Although Charlie’s injury was not directly his employer’s fault, he was able to file a successful workers’ compensation claim to cover his medical costs and other needs. At no given time was William held financially responsible for what happened to his colleague.

Making a False or Fraudulent Representation or Statement

When it comes to filing a workers’ compensation claim, a false or fraudulent representation or statement could be made regarding the following:

  • The statement made orally or in writing by the claimant
  • The notice a claimant makes regarding their injury
  • Payments made for specific services, like medical care
  • The proof of injury provided in the claim
  • Medical records
  • Diagnostic results from tests, X-rays, and MRIs
  • Evidence provided regarding medical and legal expenses incurred
  • Any additional evidence provided to support the claim

Example: Mercy works at the front desk of a successful financial firm. She sustains a serious leg injury during an altercation involving an aggrieved client and one of the senior partners. After receiving treatment in a hospital, she still needs to see a physical therapist twice weekly to recover full mobility of her leg. However, she does not keep up with the schedule after a few weeks of treatment.

Without Mercy’s knowledge, her physical therapist bills her workers’ compensation insurer for all scheduled treatments, including the ones she has not received treatment for. In that case, the false bills constitute false representations or statements that could support a workers’ compensation fraud case.

This law also prohibits making false or fraudulent material representations or statements to receive benefits you do not deserve. A statement becomes material when it provides information that is pertinent to an investigation by an insurance company regarding a workers’ compensation claim. A material statement can influence the investigation or evaluation of a worker’s comp[ensation claim.

Example: Before John’s accident at work, he had a pre-existing leg injury that he sustained while hiking with his friends. However, when applying for benefits, he did not disclose the original cause of his leg injury. His insurance company granted his claim based on the statements he made regarding the workplace accident and the extent of his injury.

John knew that disclosing his initial accident could have led to reduced or denied benefits. However, failing to disclose full information to the insurance company is deemed a fraudulent act.

The Meaning of Fraudulent or False Statements

Fraudulent or false statements are untrue. They are also statements that conceal critical information that could influence an insurance company’s decision. There are many ways employees and employers make fraudulent or false statements regarding workers’ compensation. The common ones made by claimants are:

  • Faking or exaggerating an injury
  • Providing false information about the cause or severity of your injury
  • Claiming that you were injured at work, while in actuality the injury occurred somewhere else
  • Not disclosing a prior injury
  • Falsely stating that you did not file another claim for one injury
  • Obtaining multiple benefits for one injury or from multiple employers
  • Continuing to work and earn a living while still receiving benefits

Example: Terry enjoys hiking with her friends every month. In her previous hiking trip, she tripped, fell, and seriously injured her left arm. Since she did not go to the hospital right away, her injury worsened over time. She reported it to her manager after a week, attributing it to her work, which involves a lot of manual work. Her employer approved her workers’ compensation claim and allowed her some time off to recover from the injury.

Terry is guilty of insurance fraud under this law for receiving benefits for a non-work-related injury.

Employers also make fraudulent or false statements regarding workers’ compensation claims, which could result in fraud charges. Examples of such statements include:

  • Providing an inaccurate number of employees in your workplace to avoid paying the full amount needed to cover their workplace injuries
  • Lying about your workers’ job duties
  • Lying to your injured worker about the scope of their benefit to discourage them from filing a claim

Workers’ Compensation Fraud According to Penal Code Section 550

This law prohibits several fraudulent acts that mainly overlap with healthcare fraud. Basically, this statute makes the following actions unlawful:

  • Knowingly making or causing someone to give a falsified claim to obtain healthcare benefits covered under the compensation scheme
  • Knowingly submitting a healthcare benefits claim covered under the compensation scheme that you did not use
  • Knowingly filing multiple claims to receive more benefits than you deserve from a workers’ compensation insurer. Thus, the prosecutor must prove that you intended to defraud the insurance provider.

Although those who violate this statute are mainly employees and employers, medical professionals, doctors, and healthcare providers also violate it, especially those who treat patients covered under the California workers’ compensation scheme.

Example: Joanne is a physical therapist who primarily serves workers who have sustained workplace injuries. Sometimes, she files exaggerated claims to insurance companies to receive payment for services that her patients have not received. If she is arrested, Joanne will likely face fraud charges under Section 550 of California Penal Law.

Note: Any medical professional who is convicted under this law will likely lose their professional license. This is an additional penalty to the criminal penalties provided for the offense under the law.

Workers’ Compensation Fraud According to Penal Code Section 549

This law prohibits employees or business owners from accepting, soliciting, or referring clients from or to any business or person, knowing or recklessly disregarding that the business or person intends to violate this law. This law mainly applies to medical professionals treating patients covered under the California workers’ compensation scheme.

Also, this law primarily applies to people who commit commercial bribery by soliciting, receiving, or offering kickbacks to defraud the workers’ compensation scheme.

Penalties for a Conviction for Defrauding the Workers’ Compensation Scheme

If charged, and the prosecutor proves all elements of your crime beyond a reasonable doubt, the judge will issue penalties according to the exact law you have violated.

For example, if the prosecutor filed charges under California Insurance Code Section 1871.4, this is a wobbler. This means your charges will be either a felony or a misdemeanor. A conviction for a misdemeanor under this law is punishable by a maximum of one year in jail, or summary probation, and a court fine of $150,000 or twice the amount of fraud (the greater amount). The court can also compel you to pay victim restitution.

On the other hand, if convicted of a felony under this statute, your penalties will be two, three, or five years in prison, a jail sentence of two, three, or five years under the realignment program, or formal probation, and a court fine of $150,000, or twice the amount of fraud (the judge will choose the greater amount). You could also be ordered to pay restitution to the victim.

If convicted of workers’ compensation under Section 550 of the Penal Law, this, too, is a wobbler. The penalties for a misdemeanor may include a one-year jail sentence and a $10,000 fine. The judge can sentence you to misdemeanor probation for up to 5 years. On the other hand, a felony probation is punishable by two, three, or five years in prison or felony probation for up to five years, and a $50,000 fine.

However, the law has an exception here. The exception applies when the fraud amount is $950 or lower (including an aggregate of several claims for up to 12 months). In this case, the DA will only bring misdemeanor charges against you, punishable by six months in jail and $1000 in court fines.

If convicted under Penal Code Section 549, this is a wobbler only for first offenders; subsequent offenders face felony charges. The penalties for a misdemeanor may include a one-year jail sentence and a $50,000 in fine (or twice the fraud amount if greater). The penalties for a felony include 16 months, two years, or three years in prison, and a $50,000 fine.

Other Conviction Consequences

In addition to the criminal penalties listed here, other consequences may affect various aspects of your life. These consequences are as follows:

  1. Professional Discipline

If you hold a professional license, like a doctor, nurse, pharmacist, or physical therapist, a conviction for defrauding the workers’ compensation scheme will lead to professional discipline. In California, a criminal conviction that substantially relates to your qualifications, duties, or functions as a professional license holder will result in professional discipline. After an investigation, your licensing body can suspend or revoke your license, depending on the gravity of the matter.

  1. A Severe Criminal Record

A criminal conviction always ends up on your record, which is accessible to the public. A conviction for a misdemeanor stays on your record for up to ten years, while a felony remains on your record for life. Anyone who checks your criminal record will learn about the crime, which may affect your professional and social lives. For example, if a prospective employer finds out about your conviction, they may decide not to hire you regardless of your qualifications. A landlord may decide not to rent to you, and an insurance provider can determine your rates based on your criminal background.

  1. Civil Penalties

Certain types of workers’ compensation fraud will result in serious civil fines. In most cases, these penalties apply to anyone who is found guilty of:

  • Willfully misrepresenting facts to pay a lower amount to a workers' compensation insurance scheme. This mainly applies to employers.
  • Presenting or causing another person to knowingly present a fraudulent or false statement to support or oppose a workers’ compensation benefit claim
  • Knowingly receiving, offering, paying, accepting, or soliciting illegal refunds, rebates, commissions, or other forms of compensation for referring or receiving clients for any service covered under the California workers’ compensation scheme.
  • Knowingly operating or participating in the delivery of any service that includes referring patients to receive a medical service covered under the California workers’ compensation scheme, for a profit.
  • Knowingly conspiring with or assisting a person with the above.

If found guilty of any of these, you could be charged a civil fine of $4,000 to $10,000 for any illegal compensation claim submitted. You could also be held liable for a maximum assessment of three times the money paid by the workers’ compensation for the fraudulent medical expense.

Additionally, if there is a prior record of a felony conviction on your criminal record for insurance fraud, the judge will impose additional civil penalties of $4000, at least for every service or item related to your fraudulent acts.

Defending Yourself Against Charges for Workers Compensation Fraud

A conviction under any of the laws mentioned here can result in serious criminal penalties and other life-changing consequences. Thus, you should fight during the trial to avoid a conviction or convince the court to reduce your charges. You can do this with the help of a competent criminal attorney. Some of the strategies your lawyer can use in your defense include the following:

Proving that You Did Not Have a Fraudulent Intent

One of the critical elements of a fraud-related crime is having a fraudulent or criminal intent. In your case, the prosecutor must prove that your actions were willful and that you intended to obtain benefits you did not deserve or deny someone benefits they deserved. This is the only way the court will find you guilty. If you did not have a fraudulent or criminal intent, the court will drop your charges.

With the help of your attorney, you can prove that although you acted the way you did, you did not know that your actions or statements would result in fraud. This could be the case if you believed that your statements or support document were accurate.

You can also use this strategy if you made an honest mistake when representing facts about your case.

However, the burden of proof always lies with the prosecution. If the DA fails to prove that you had a fraudulent intent, your skilled attorney can convince the court to drop your charges.

The Prosecution Lacks Adequate Evidence

Remember that the burden to prove criminal cases always lies with the prosecution. The district attorney must prove the case for the court to enter a guilty verdict. This burden is difficult to meet if the evidence against you is insufficient.

For example, the prosecutor must prove that your actions were willful and not accidental. They must prove your fraudulent intent. Without enough proof, achieving this can be challenging. A skilled attorney can use that to convince the court to drop your charges.

Find a Proficient Criminal Defense Lawyer Near Me

If charged with workers’ compensation fraud and are in Orange County, your first action should be to hire a proficient defense lawyer. They will ensure you understand your charges, your options, your civil rights, and the best defense strategies for the best possible outcome. We can help you fight for a fair outcome at Orange County Criminal Defense. Our team of highly trained and experienced defense attorneys will work alongside you until you are pleased with your case’s outcome. Contact us at 657-600-0945 to learn more about us.